Why Selling Natural Products is Such a Dangerous Business
Alliance for Natural Health
Tue, 13 Sep 2011 18:47 CDT
Federal Law for Sellers of Food, Supplements, and Medical Devices
The Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FD&C) gives authority to the FDA to regulate interstate commerce of supplements, drugs, and devices. According to the FD&C, by definition, only drugs can claim to cure, prevent, mitigate, or treat a disease [section 201(g)]. Nothing else may make that claim - certainly not a food or supplement.
To legally market a drug (that is, any substance that can claim to cure, prevent, mitigate, or treat a disease), it must go through the lengthy and expensive FDA drug approval process. Any violation - that is, any sale of a "drug" that is not FDA-approved - can lead to seizure of the product, injunctions against its sale and distribution, and criminal penalties, including imprisonment, for the manufacturer.
And as we have noted many times before, if a substance is natural, it is not patentable, and companies can only recoup their huge investment (as much as a billion on average, although estimates vary) in FDA approval if they can make it up through the high prices that patent protection makes possible. Therefore, natural products in supplement form will never be able to claim to treat disease, including cancer [section 201(ff)].
Why Only Patentable Drugs Are Considered "Safe"
The FDA's control over patients' access to cancer drugs was challenged in a 1979 lawsuit, United States v. Rutherford. Terminally ill cancer patients sued to stop the FDA from preventing the interstate shipment and sale of Laetrile - a modified form of amygdalin, a naturally occurring substance found in apricot pits as well as in other plants. The Supreme Court determined that the FD&C :
"makes no express exceptions for drugs used by the terminally ill... Exceptions to clearly delineated statutes will be implied only where essential to prevent 'absurd results' or consequences obviously at variance with the policy of the enactment as a whole."
The Court supported FDA's position that terminally ill cancer patients must be ensured therapeutic gain, which is only "guaranteed" by FDA approval. What this means in effect is that only non-natural and therefore patentable drugs which can be brought through the FDA process are "safe" enough to be used, even though natural remedies, which our bodies have evolved with, are generally safer or at least more predictable in their effects.
The further irony here, of course, is that the FDA has often approved drugs that are outrageously unsafe, causing so many deaths that they are subsequently pulled from the market and banned.
The US National Poison Data System's latest report records only a single death concurrent with supplement use - an "unknown dietary supplement or homeopathic agent" - with no deaths reported before 2009. On the other hand, it shows that, of all products to which we are exposed that might cause harm, pharmaceutical drugs caused 80% of fatalities
Even though supplements cannot claim to prevent or treat disease, everyone knows that they may often be used for this purpose, either by consumers who have studied the scientific research, or by doctors themselves.
FTC Currently Violating the Law
The Federal Trade Commission code contains both a general prohibition of unfair or deceptive acts or practices affecting commerce [15 USC 45(s)] and a provision specifically prohibiting false or deceptive advertising of foods, drugs, devices, or cosmetics [15 USC 52]. In other words, the FTC has authority to stop false advertising of drugs and supplements as well as unconventional treatments it deems to be false medical cures - including cancer treatments.
Unfortunately, as we reported this past April, the FTC has recently created new and arbitrary requirements for ANY food or dietary supplement health-related claim - and is enforcing them - in direct violation of federal law. The FTC is now requiring two random-controlled human trials for any health-related claim - even so-called structure/function claims, which are permitted under the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994 (DSHEA) without such trials. In response, ANH-USA and our co-plaintiffs, Durk Pearson and Sandy Shaw, filed a Petition for Rulemaking before the FTC. This petition, if denied, will lead to a litigation phase.
Often the FDA and the FTC work together to target supplement and food companies, which is precisely why the Free Speech About Science Act is so important. There are also federal criminal statutes that might affect the marketing and advertising of unconventional cancer treatments, like the wire fraud statute, which prohibits use of telephone, radio, or television to make "false representations for products and services," and the federal smuggling statute.
Given all these legal risks, producers of natural food, supplements, and devices deserve our thanks.
Why Selling Natural Products is Such a Dangerous Business To legally market a drug (that is, any substance that can claim to cure, prevent, mitigate, or treat a disease), it must go through the lengthy and expensive FDA drug approval process. Any violation - that is, any sale of a "drug" that is not FDA-approved - can lead to seizure of the product, injunctions against its sale and distribution, and criminal penalties, including imprisonment, for the manufacturer.
Soursop Fruit 100 Fold Stronger At Killing Cancer Than Chemotherapy. Besides being a cancer remedy, graviola is a broad spectrum antimicrobial agent for both bacterial and fungal infections, is effective against internal parasites and worms, lowers high blood pressure and is used for depression, stress and nervous disorders.
The Health Benefits of Cloves. The active principles in the clove are known to have antioxidant, anti-septic, local anesthetic, anti-inflammatory, rubefacient (warming and soothing), carminative and anti-flatulent properties.
Comfrey. Healing for wounds, and helpful in high blood pressure, diabetes, and more.
Cardamonin, inhibits pro-inflammatory mediators in activated RAW 264.7 cells and whole blood. Cardamonin acts upon major pro-inflammatory mediators.
Chelerythrine. Chelerythrine is a benzophenanthridine alkaloid extracted from the plant Greater celandine (Chelidonium majus) and from Blood Root (Sanguinaria canadensis). It is a potent, selective, and cell-permeable protein kinase C inhibitor (may improve mood and benefit the heart, is used in several anti-cancer drugs).
What is Nigella Sativa? (Jintan Hitam). Black seed is used for treating gastrointestinal conditions including gas, colic, diarrhea, dysentery, constipation and haemorrhoids. It is also used for respiratory conditions, including asthma, allergies, cough, bronchitis, emphysema, flu and congestion. Additionally, it is used as an antihypertensive, immunoprotectant, anticancer agent, and vermifuge.
About BSI Mangiferin. The colorful history of Mangiferin dates more than 1000 years, a mainstay of Chinese medicine, Balean medicine in Indonesia, and ethno-medicine in Cuba.
Keladi tikus / Typhonium flagelliforme (Lodd.) Bl. The type of cancer that can be inhibited by rodent tuber is in addition to breast cancer nasopharyngeal cancer, liver, cancer of the cervix, pancreas, prostate, lung and many more. In addition to cancer, according to some studies also mentioned that taro rats can be used for people who have drug addiction.
Noni Fruit and Juice and its Benefits. Noni mimics the secretion coming from the pineal gland, and in fact acts as a precursor to it, building it up and allowing it to function fully. It is a noted analgesic or pain reliever.
California Poppy. The California poppy contains protopine, which has similar (but much milder effects) as morphine, making it a good natural sedative.
Research: Pineapple Bromelain Enzyme Kills Cancer Without Killing You. How then, can something as innocuous as the enzyme from the stem/core of a pineapple be superior to a drug that millions of cancers patients over the past 40 years have placed their hopes of recovery on, as well as exchanging billions of dollars for?
Health Benefits of Aloe Vera. Not only does it contain vitamin B12 but several other minerals that are important for the health of our bodies. Aloe vera also contains calcium, protein, zinc, magnesium, vitamins A, and E, germanium, essential fatty acids and amino acids.
The Magic Duo for Cancer Treatment That Frightens The FDA and Conventional Medicine: DMSO.Dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), a by-product of the wood industry, has been in use as a commercial solvent since 1953. DMSO can carry other drugs with it across membranes. It is more successful ferrying some drugs, such as morphine sulfate, penicillin, steroids, and cortisone, than others, such as insulin. What it will carry depends on the molecular weight, shape, and electrochemistry of the molecules. This property would enable DMSO to act as a new drug delivery system that would lower the risk of infection occurring whenever skin is penetrated.
6 Benefits of Papaya Leaves to the Human Body One supplement you should not overlook is Papaya Leaf Extract. Papayas are excellent sources of dietary fiber, vitamin C, vitamin A, vitamin E, and folate, while at the same time being rich in antioxidants, flavonoids, and carotenes. Papayas also contain high amounts of enzymes called papain and chymopapain, which are critical ingredients for a healthy body.
Health Benefits of Pine Essential Oil. The health benefits of pine essential oil include its ability to reduce inflammation and associated redness, protect against sinus infections, clear mucus and phlegm, cure skin conditions like eczema and psoriasis, boost the immune system, fight fungal and viral infections, stimulate the mind and body, and protecting your home and body from a wide variety of germs.
Gelatin Capsules Sizes and shapes of Gelatin Capsules.
All About Zinc. Zinc is an essential element, necessary for sustaining all life. It is estimated that 3000 of the hundreds of thousands of proteins in the human body contain zinc. Signs of zinc deficiency includes hair loss, skin lesions, diarrhea, wasting of body tissues. Prolonged lack of zinc can result in death.
Master Index of Health-Related Articles on BSI.International